CSR in Banking - Current strategies
Success in the banking industry is largely based on the trust of clients. In terms of services and products related to CSR there are hardly any differences to be found and even if there are any, their importance will not tell a bank apart from the rest at all. On the other side, what really differs, is the influence of a bank on their shareholders (term explained in the section "What is it?") Ethical behaviour seems to tip the scale which decides about thriving life or doomed existence in this industry. Banking institution hold often lifelong savings in trust, therefore nobody can be surprised, that customers really do care about social responsible activities of their bank. If you lend a car to your friend, usually you know from past experience and behaviour, that he’s a good person. So that there is no need to worry about whether the car will get back or nor. If this works in interpersonal relations, why not in business?
Let’s look at the CSR strategies of the biggest banks:
Bank of America (USA) – market capitalization 196 billion USD
This biggest American bank based its strategy on 5 pillars:
Community Development
This goal involves Transforming Communities which help people to overcome their financial needs. Main focus groups are low income workers with local activities. They are offered special loans, mortgages and other financial instruments in order to support different communities. These activities are coordinated with local organizations (e.g. Local Initiatives Support Corporation)
Corporate Philanthropy
“We believe, very simply, that it is the actions of individuals working together that build strong communities ... and that business has an obligation to support those actions in the communities it serves.” words from Kenneth D. Lewis, Chairman and CEO, with which he described the main philanthropic strategy of the bank. By this programme volunteering, tertiary education, NGOs and regional activities are supported.
Environment
„Damage to our environment threatens the long-term sustainability of our economy, our prosperity and our way of life. At Bank of America, our environmental policies are shaped by our conviction that the health of our company is dependent on the health of communities and our society“. This is the reason which the company engages in environment protection. The bank has obliged itself that it will decrease its impact on environment in three ways:
- Impact reduction (recycling, waste and energy reduction etc.)
- Environmental Products and Services
- Associate involvement (cooperation in environmental campaigns)
Sponsorship
Bank of America sponsors many regional cultural events as well as national sports like U.S. Olympic Team or NFL.
Team Bank of America
Team Bank of America is a worldwide organization through which Bank of America associates and retirees can work together to touch the lives of our customers and improve the communities around us. Within the corporation and in communities around the globe (e.g.: encourages self-initiated professional development or ,provides networking opportunities )
HSBC Holdings (UK) – market capitalization 177 billion USD
For HSBC, the biggest European bank, CSR means managing their business responsibly and sensitively for long-term success. Their goal is not, and never has been, profit at any cost because they know that tomorrow's success depends on the trust they build today.
CSR strategy:
Personal Financial Services (including consumer finance)
o Financial inclusion and consumer debt, secure and convenient delivery channels, customer satisfaction
Commercial banking
o Environmental credit risk needs to be managed carefully to minimise ecological damage caused indirectly through financing, Emerging markets pose certain regulatory and ethical risks,
Corporate, Investment Banking and Markets (CIBM)
o Social, environmental and financial risks and opportunities of major projects (special system developed in 2004 „From Risk to Opportunity“)
Private Banking
o Money laundering and financial crime (thorough control and security measures), Determining the legitimacy of the source of an individual’s wealth.
Citigroup (USA) – market capitalization 141 billion USD
The second biggest American bank believes that compliance with ethical standards is crucial in order to reach world-class business standards.
Overview of CSR:
At Citi, they believe that working to promote environmental and social sustainability is good business practice. As a global corporate citizen, they view sustainability issues from both a risk and an opportunity perspective. They analyze the potential impacts of their business activities and take action to reduce environmental risk and impact. They also look for opportunities to make sustainable investments and develop products and services with positive environmental and social impacts.
Three pillars:
1) Evironment
In January 2006, Citi announced the goal of reducing our global emissions by 10% from our 2005 level by the year 2011. In other initiatives, Citi is working with IT equipment manufacturers to achieve greater heating and cooling efficiency.
In 2004 and 2005, Citigroup used paper certified by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) in our annual Citizenship Report. FSC is an organization that has set the international gold standard for environmentally appropriate, socially beneficial, and economically viable forest management.
- Citi business initiatives
Climate change (On May 8, 2007, Citi announced that it will direct $50 billion over the next 10 years to address global climate change through investments, financings and related activities), Environmental and Social Risk Management (ESRM) Policy (In 2003, Citi’s Markets and Banking (CMB) division developed an Environmental and Social Risk Management (ESRM) Policy to help address environmental and social issues from both a credit risk perspective and a reputation and franchise risk perspective), Equator Principles (Citi was one of the original institutions that spearheaded the development of the Equator Principles, which apply to project finance transactions in all industry sectors globally, including mining, oil and gas, power, and forestry), , Forestry (Citi is connected with and committed to the efforts to sustain healthy forest systéme), Sustainable Development Investments (Their Sustainable Development Investments group (SDI) operates as a standalone investment center within the Citi Alternative Investments (CAI) division.)
Citi works closely with a range of external organizations, including non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and a network of socially responsible investors (SRIs).
2) Citi volunteerism
Volunteerism has long been an integral part of Citi’s culture. For nearly 200 years, Citi’s legacy of innovation and achievement has been part of the fabric of thousands of communities around the world. Every day around the world, their employees put their passion, talent, and expertise to work by helping organizations and causes they believe in, ultimately helping to improve their communities.
Actions:
Employee Volunteer Day, Volunteer Incentive Program, Volunteer Management Systém, Global Community Day
3) Citi Financial Education Program
Citi and the Citi Foundation celebrated the third anniversary of their unprecedented 10-year, $200 million global commitment to Financial Education. In 2006, Citi and the Citi Foundation invested nearly $32 million in 72 countries, for a total of nearly $85 million to date putting us well ahead of schedule. Combined, the Citi Foundation and Citi-sponsored programs have touched the lives of more than 3.5 million people worldwide.
At the beginning of February 2008 JP Morgan Chase, Morgan Stanley and Citi announced their intention to set and comply with Carbon principles which stand for a new framework to understand and evaluate the carbon risk and mitigation options.
One of the main European financial services companies has worked out its CSR strategy thoroughly and most extensively. We do not dare to list and interpret all the activities and principles, for CSR in Société Générale click here.
In this section we briefly introduced the CSR strategies of a few large banks. All in all, we do not see much difference in the key pillars – each bank has programmes to protect the environment, support communities and charities. Surprising fact may be that most elaborated strategies we can find in environmental protection; although banks do not impact it directly. More future-oriented finding lies in big reserves in employees care. As mentioned before, employees satisfaction belongs to the priorities for the success in banking.