Who Has More to Gain?
Published at: 15/02/11
Concept development
211
269
As you already know, BenKing aims to help those creative students, passionate about banking, by offering them the opportunity to learn from Societe Generale professionals. But which are the benefits for SG, why would they become partners in such a project?

![]()
Besides social responsibility that is going to foster the economic growth in Romania, SG can benefit from the fresh and innovative ideas students have. Creativity has no limits in the young minds of the students. Knowing and feeling the environment is another advantage they have. It is more difficult to sense and understand the needs of the target markets as an employee. However, it is easier for those inside the market to think about what is missing in their community and to find a way to fill that gap.
What is more, BRD SG is having a direct and easy access to the brightest, passionate and creative students from the Academy of Economic Studies. Recruitment is therefore possible, considering the fact that all multinationals are fighting for dedicated, innovative employees. Those students that are most in line with the values of SG can become interns or employees, bringing value added to the company.
Finally, BRD is building brand awareness among the students’ community, becoming even more visible as they offer exactly what the students are missing: the chance to learn, to apply what you know, to be creative and to do that for good.
To sum up, BenKing is a win-win solution to the educational and economic environment in Romania. Both SG, the participants and the organizers – the BenKing team – will have an enriching experience. However, some feel that this is just another way to take advanatage of the students’ creativity…What do you think? Who has more to gain, students or the bank?
I think that wining should be in the same proportions for the both sides
win-win situation
Exactly, both are on the win side.
students and the bank, both are on the win side
I believe it really depends on the innovative product that students will create. It may be a very profitable product for the bank or it may be not so profitable but very useful for the community. On the other hand, it's obvious that students involved in this project gain more than the community does. And even though they may not earn money for their invention they gain experience and know-how, which are a lot more powerful because they are able to generate a lot of money in the future.
I do agree with what Octavian said: the bank wins a lot more, because they get access to the students' creativity, which can be a very powerful tool in the right hands (minds in this example)!
Nice idea, I believe that the best way of learning is through practicing and not by only reading courses.
I also think that BRD is one of the banks that really get involved in the community, unlike others.
BRD is great if involves so much in our education
We are glad that our project is creating such debates! You have given us some insights and we thank you for that!
Maybe exploitation is a little bit too much. However, this is a point of view 'cause the boundary is very thin and we need to rely on the bank's ethics...
@ Andreea Simion I`m not saying that a company shouldn`t be socially responsible,by contrary, I admire such a decision, but I just didn`t see the connection between this domain and banking- I always thought CSR was more about the environment and needy people. From what you said, I can conclude that BenKing can also be considered as comprising social responsibility because it is aimed at educating students, am I right? @ Ioana Why do you consider it exploitation? If students will develop products which will be later used by the bank, this is to the benefit of both parties: BRD will find out the needs of the students/ clients, and those who created the product will benefit from the experience.
I also consider there are mutual advantages . As well i as i know , Benking is a project that provides for students the chance to be more motivated and to realise that , if they want , they have the opportunity to change their life . Moreover ,if students are more interested to revolutionise the banking system , banks will pay more attention to their ideas and from here , we can notice the mutual advantage
It depends on how you look at the situation. Of course SG has a lot to gain, but without such projects, the students have very few opportunities for growth,
@Ioana You have an interesting point here but you forget a very important element : the main role of BenKing, which is precisely that of providing a suitable environment to foster the advantages of both parts in their collaboration. At least that's what I understood from this article and previous ones. As far as I am concerned, I can only welcome such an opportunity and look forward to participating to it ; social responsibility also means to open "doors " for improvement in education and create a long term well sustained system for coming generations, and that is exactly what BenKing and BRD SG would do.
Well, sometimes students can be considered a little stupid, but if they don't get the chance to express themselves and prove their potential we can only stick to that preconception. Than it's to be seen in what form will the ideas provided by the students be used and if their benefits will be in direct proportion with the value of what they create. There will be no Social Responsibility, but Social Exploitation... don't you think?
I think the bank wins a lot more, because they get access to the students' creativity, which can be a very powerful tool in the right hands (minds in this example), and I think one must pay a lot for a specific brainstorming:)
@Teodora From my point of view banking products have a lot to do with social responsibility. Think only about the amount of persons that have credit or debit cards and they don't know how to use them properly or they don't know what are the benefits they have and this is only because there isn't enough information and some things should be learned in school. That's why this project is so beneficial (both for the students and for the bank) they will find out more things about the products they are already using and they will have their moment too because they will have the chance to invent something new and more than that something that they are missing at this point.I hope I was able to answer your question.
Indeed, the students are more likely to take advantage of such an opportunity but I also think BRD SG would certainly gain access to the best students in this field. To my mind, what really matters for their brand awareness is that more and more students learn about these opportunities. And how else can they get to students if not by a project which brings together both theoretical (faculty)and practical (bank) worlds?
Which shall be the most important criteria when selecting the students that will be able to participate? Are you not concerned of the possibility that their level won't rise at the expectations of the bank?
@Teodora I think social responsability is something that every company should have. It's not that the company is responsible to the environment only, but also to it's employees. Let's see the big picture, will we?
The way I see it, by developing the BenKing project, Societe Generale can become the bank that bring a fresh flow of banking products every year. And these products will consider the needs in every community and help students at the same time. Therefore BenKing can be developed as a strong CSR project. It is obvious that Societe Generale has a lot of benefits by implemeting this project, but what are the stakes we should have in mind?
Students are definitely more motivated by the idea of winning a contest than by passing an exam. What is more, I totally agree to Camelia that what you learn by training, in practice, is going to be remembered much more than the simple and always-the same courses in the university.
@Teodora I think that there is social responsibility in creating banking products that are not primarily focused on profit making, but on meeting and responding to the needs of the communities to which they address.
Hey, As you said, to us, the Romanian students the need of practical experience is huge. We are à vrai dire starving from this point of view. BenKing should eventually help us say at the end of the 3 years of faculty (FABBV especially) that we have the solid basis to enter the labor market. Do you agree with me that we are more likely to remember what we have been taught if we take part in a training program, where we can work on a case study, where we can be evaluated by professionals, not by professors and where we are more motivated by a determination to win (if it would be the case of a competition) than a simple grade?
But what does social responsibility have to do with banking products?
I think that students have more to gain! But it is not useless for banks either.